How Parks are Rated

This page explains the rating scale used on I Love National Parks.  First, while the ratings are as objective as possible, they are still based on the subjective views of one person--me!  Why rate Parks?   I feel it's important to give folks interested in visiting National Parks an tool for making decisions based on what's important to them.  National Parks are rated on four distinct areas, Scenery, Uniqueness, Wildlife and Diversity.

Scenery:  How breathtaking and spectacular is the landscape, color, contrast, etc. of the Park?
Uniqueness:  How special is this Park?  Is this the only place you can see these sights?
Wildlife:  How many animals can you expect to see?  How many species?  Bear, Moose or lizards?
Diversity:  How many different activities and ways to see the Park are there?  How unique are different parts of the Park?

All Parks are then rated based on where they stand in each area compared to other National Parks.

4star.gif (1543 bytes) The best! Only a few other National Parks rival it
3star.gif (1361 bytes) Superior, better than most other National Parks
2star.gif (1361 bytes) Average, what you would expect from most National Parks
1star.gif (1361 bytes) Below average, most National Parks are better

These ratings, are then loosely combined to get the overall Park rating (the big stars at the top of each rating block).  To view my ranking of the National Parks I've been to, click here.  Here's basically what each star on the overall rating implies.

4star.gif (1543 bytes) Consider planning a vacation to just to see this Park
3star.gif (1361 bytes) Consider a weekend trip or incorporating time into a larger vacation to see this Park
2star.gif (1361 bytes) Consider a detour or day trip to see this Park
1star.gif (1361 bytes) Consider seeing this Park if you're in the area and have time

And the half stars?  Well, somewhere in between.  On priciple, I consider every National Park worth at least a day trip, so don't expect to see many 1-star overall ratings.  1-star is generally reserved for the four categories.

National Monuments and other places are only given an overall rating.  Because they're not National Parks, I don't hold them to the same standard.  A good rule of thumb for a National Monument ratings is to knock off one star and apply the NP matrix above, so a "3-star" rating would mean "consider a detour or day trip to see this Monument." 

Hope this helps!


site links: home | national parks | monuments & such | nature photos | map | facts and fun | resources & lynx | sitemap | about the site